Login| Sign Up| Help| Contact|

Patent Searching and Data


Title:
MACHINE TOOL
Document Type and Number:
WIPO Patent Application WO/2023/144613
Kind Code:
A1
Abstract:
The present invention relates to a machine tool (1) for chip removal processing comprising an upright (2), a bench (3) and a machining group ( 4 ). The upright (2) has a prevailing extension along a vertical axis (Y) orthogonal to a base plane (B) for supporting the machine. The upright (2) has a front side (20) lying on a front upright plane (Em) and a rear side (22) lying on a rear upright plane (Pm). Such front side (20) and rear side (22) are connected to each other by a right side (24) and a left side (26). The bench (3) has a prevailing extension along a longitudinal axis (X) and is suitable to be fixed to the base plane (B). The machining group (4) is connected to the upright in such a way as to be translatable along the vertical axis (Y) and along an advancement axis (Z) that is orthogonal to both the vertical axis (Y) and the longitudinal axis (X). Such machining group is suitable to perform the chip removal operations on a workpiece. The upright (2) comprises a front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) and a rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) suitable to engage the machining group (4). The front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) and the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) adjust the vertical translation of machining group (4) and keep the machining group orthogonal to the vertical axis (Y).

Inventors:
CODINI ROBERTO (IT)
ADORNI FRANCO GIUSEPPE (IT)
Application Number:
PCT/IB2022/062280
Publication Date:
August 03, 2023
Filing Date:
December 15, 2022
Export Citation:
Click for automatic bibliography generation   Help
Assignee:
INNSE BERARDI S P A SOC UNIPERSONALE (IT)
International Classes:
B23Q1/62; B23Q5/40; B23Q11/00
Domestic Patent References:
WO2017158059A12017-09-21
WO2017158090A12017-09-21
Foreign References:
DE102013207125A12014-10-23
Attorney, Agent or Firm:
ZANARDELLI, Davide et al. (IT)
Download PDF:
Claims:
CLAIMS

1. A machine tool (1) for chip removal processing, e.g., a drilling machine or a milling-boring machine, comprising :

- an upright (2) having a prevailing extension along a vertical axis (Y) substantially orthogonal to a base plane (B) for supporting the machine, wherein the upright (2) has a front side (20) lying on a front upright plane (Fm) and a rear side (22) lying on a rear upright plane (Pm) , said front side (20) and rear side (22) being connected to each other by a right side (24) and a left side (26) , the upright further comprising a base support (28) ; a bench (3) having a prevailing extension along a longitudinal axis (X) and being suitable to be fixed to the base plane (B) , said bench being further engaged by the base support (28) , so as to make the upright (2) longitudinally translatable on the bench (3) ;

- a machining group (4) connected to the upright to be translatable along the vertical axis (Y) and along an advancement axis (Z) orthogonal to both the vertical axis (Y) and the longitudinal axis (X) , said machining group being suitable to perform the chip removal operations on a workpiece, wherein the upright (2) comprises a front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) and a rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) suitable to engage the machining group (4) , and wherein the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) and the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) adjust the vertical translation of the machining group (4) and keep the machining group orthogonal to the vertical axis (Y) .

2. A machine tool (1) according to claim 1, wherein a machining group (4) comprises:

- a carriage (40) delimited by a front end engaged to the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) and a rear end engaged to the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) so as to translate vertically along the vertical axis (Y) , said front end lying on a carriage front plane (Fc) and said rear end lying on a carriage rear plane (Pc) ;

- a slide (41) , preferably a RAM slide, housed in the carriage (40) to translate along the advancement axis (Z) , said slide (41) comprising a tool-holder table (42) , preferably provided with a spindle rotatable relative to a machining axis (W) , the tool-holder table (42) being further suitable to house a machining tool, wherein the translation along the advancement axis (Z) of the slide relative to the carriage horizontally displaces the position of a center of gravity (Gl) of the machining group, the center of gravity (Gl) of the machining group being positioned between an imaginary front plane (If) , which connects the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) , and an imaginary rear plane (Ip) , which connects the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54 ) , and wherein the front pair of vertical translation means (51,

53) and the rear pair of vertical translation means (52,

54) keep the carriage front plane (Fc) parallel to the front upright plane (Fm) independently of the position of the center of gravity (Gl) of the machining group (4) .

3. A machine tool (1) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) comprises a front pair of actuating gear motors (510, 530) and a front pair of ball screws (510', 530' ) , wherein a first gear motor (510) actuates the first ball screw (510' ) and the second gear motor (530) actuates the second ball screw (530' ) .

4. A machine tool (1) according to the preceding claim, wherein the first gear motor is the master and the second gear motor is the slave.

5. A machine tool (1) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) comprises a rear pair of actuating gear motors (520, 540) and a rear pair of ball screws (520', 540' ) , wherein a third gear motor (520) actuates the third ball screw (520' ) and the fourth gear motor (540) actuates the fourth ball screw (540' ) .

6. A machine tool (1) according to the preceding claim, wherein the third gear motor is the master and the fourth gear motor is the slave.

7. A machine tool (1) according to claims 4 and 6, wherein the first gear motor is the master relative to the third gear motor, so as to make the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) the slave relative to the first gear motor (510) .

8. A machine tool (1) according to any one of the preceding claims in combination with claim 2, wherein the slide (41) is movable between a forward position, wherein the center of gravity (Gl) of the machining group (4) is near the front imaginary plane (If) and the tool-holder table (42) tends to bend downward, and a retracted position, wherein the center of gravity (Gl) of the machining group (4) is near the rear imaginary plane (Ip) and the tool-holder table (42) tends to bend upward, and wherein between the forward position and the retracted position there is an intermediate equilibrium position, wherein the center of gravity (Gl) of the machining group (4) is at an intermediate position between the front imaginary plane (If) and the rear imaginary plane (Ip) so that the front carriage plane (Fc) is parallel to the front upright plane (Fm) and the force applied by the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) is substantially coincident with the force applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) .

9. A machine tool (1) according to the preceding claim, wherein, in the forward position, the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) apply a force directed upwards which is greater than the one applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) so as to restore the parallelism between the front plane of the carriage (Fc) and the front upright plane (Fm) , in particular, said front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) counteract the downward bending of the toolholder table (42) by vertically translating the carriage upwards with a front force which is greater than the rear force with which the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) vertically translate the carriage upwards.

10. A machine tool (1) according to claim 8 or 9, wherein, in the retracted position, the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) apply a force directed upwards which is smaller than the one applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) so as to restore parallelism between the front plane of the carriage (Fc) and the front upright plane (Fm) , in particular, said front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) counteract the upward bending of the tool-holder table by vertically translating the carriage upwards with a front force which is smaller than the rear force with which the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) vertically translate the carriage upwards.

11. A machine tool (1) according to any one of the preceding claims, comprising a first position sensor

(61) , e.g. a first optical scale, for controlling the positioning of the front pair of vertical translation means ( 51 , 53 ) .

12. A machine tool (1) according to any one of the preceding claims, comprising a second position sensor

(62) , e.g., a second optical scale, for controlling the positioning of the rear pair of vertical translation means ( 52 , 54 ) .

13. A machine tool (1) according to any one of claims from 8 to 10, wherein there is a control unit configured to manage the open-loop operation of the machine, the position of each slide (41) having been tested, the control unit controls the movement of the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) and the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) , so as to keep the carriage front plane (Fc) always parallel to the front upright plane (Fm) .

14. A machine tool (1) according to any one of claims from 8 to 10, wherein there is a control unit configured to manage the closed-loop operation of the machine, the control unit, receiving the position signals from the first and second optical scale, is configured to adjust the movement of the front pair of vertical translation means (51, 53) and of the rear pair of vertical translation means (52, 54) , so as to keep the carriage front plane (Fc) always parallel to the front upright plane (Fm) .

Description:
"MACHINE TOOL"

DESCRIPTION

[0001] The present invention relates to the field of machine tools , and in particular to the technical field of large machine tools .

[0002] An obj ect of the present invention is a machine tool for chip removal processing, e . g . , a drilling machine or a milling-boring machine .

[0003] As is well known, the market demand for mechanical components made with increasingly high precision requires the continuously search for new solutions that are capable of satis fying a widespread and far from resolved need . Also in the technical field of large machine tools , the challenge presented by precision mechanics is a driving force for innovation .

[0004] Unfortunately, a stable and repeatable technical solution that is capable of ensuring a level of precision of the order of tenths or hundredths of a millimeter in chip removal processing has not been identi fied yet .

[0005] The obj ect of the present invention is to propose a machine tool capable of at least partially overcoming the drawbacks mentioned above .

[0006] Said obj ect is achieved with a machine tool according to claim 1 . The dependent claims describe preferred embodiments of the invention . [0007] The features and the advantages of the machine tool according to the invention shall be made readily apparent from the following description of preferred embodiment examples thereof , provided purely by way of a nonlimiting example , with reference to the accompanying figures , wherein :

[0008] - Figure 1 is a perspective view of a machine tool in one embodiment ;

[0009] - Figure 2 is a perspective view of the machine tool of Figure 1 according to a di f ferent angle ;

[0010] - Figure 3 is a front view of the machine tool of Figure 1 ;

[0011] - Figure 4 is a sectional side view of the machine tool in a retracted position;

[0012] - Figure 4a is a sectional side view of the machine tool in an intermediate position of equilibrium;

[0013] - Figure 4b is a sectional side view of the machine tool in a forward position;

[0014] - Figure 5 is a rear perspective view of the machine tool , and

[0015] - Figure 6 is a rear perspective view of a further embodiment of the machine tool according to a di f ferent angle .

[0016] In the following description, elements common to the various embodiments represented in the drawings are indicated with the same reference numerals .

[0017] In said drawings , the reference numeral 1 is used to indicate as a whole a machine tool according to the invention .

[0018] In a general embodiment the machine tool 1 for chip removal processing operations is , e . g . , a drilling machine or a milling-boring machine . Such machine tool 1 comprises an upright 2 , a bench 3 and a machining group 4 .

[0019] The upright 2 has a prevailing extension along a vertical axis Y which is substantially orthogonal to a base plane B suitable for acting as a plane for supporting the machine . The upright 2 has a front side 20 lying on a front upright plane Fm and a rear side 22 lying on a rear upright plane Pm . The front side 20 and the rear side 22 are connected to each other by a right side 24 and a left side 26 . Finally, the upright 2 also comprises a base support 28 .

[0020] The bench 3 has a prevailing extension along a longitudinal axis X and is suitable to be fixed to the base plane B . Furthermore , the bench is engaged by the base support 28 , so as to make the upright 2 longitudinally translatable along the bench 3 .

[0021] The machining group 4 is connected to the upright in such a way as to be translatable along the vertical axis Y and along an advancement axis Z that is orthogonal to both the vertical axis Y and the longitudinal axis X . Such a machining group is suitable for performing chip removal operations on a workpiece .

[0022] Preferably, the machining group 4 has a prevailing extension along the advancement axis Z .

[0023] According to the invention, the upright 2 comprises a front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 and a rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 suitable to engage the machining group 4 . The front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 and the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 adj ust the vertical translation of machining group 4 and keep the machining group orthogonal to the vertical axis Y .

[0024] According to an embodiment , the machining group 4 comprises a carriage 40 and a slide 41 .

[0025] The carriage 40 is delimited by a front end engaged to the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 , and a rear end engaged to the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 so as to translate vertically along the vertical axis Y . The front end lies on a front carriage plane Fc and the rear end lies on a rear carriage plane Pc .

[0026] The slide 41 , preferably a RAM slide , is housed in the carriage 40 in such a way as to translate along the advancement axis Z . This slide 41 comprises a tool-holder table 42 which is preferably provided with a spindle rotatable relative to a machining axi s W .

[0027] The tool-holder table 42 is further suitable to house a machining tool . In particular, such a machining tool may be installed on the rotating spindle .

[0028] The translation along the advancement axis Z of the slide relative to the carriage hori zontally displaces the position of a center of gravity G1 of the machining group 4 . This center of gravity G1 of the machining group 4 is positioned between an imaginary front plane I f , which connects the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 , and an imaginary rear plane Ip, which connects the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 .

[0029] The front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 and the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 keep the carriage front plane Fc parallel to the front upright plane Fm independently of the position of the center of gravity G1 of machining group 4 .

[0030] For the purposes of this discussion, the term " front" and the respective derivatives thereof is to be understood as an element that is facing ( or at least near to ) the workpiece ; while the term " rear" and the respective derivatives thereof refer to an element positioned distally or in any case on an opposite side relative to the workpiece .

[0031] In this description, the terms " above" , " top" and the respective derivatives thereof refer to the machine tool in an operating condition . Similarly, the terms "under" , "bottom" and the respective derivatives thereof also refer to the machine tool that is installed and in operation .

[0032] Preferably, a skilled person may also identi fy the slide 41 using the name "head" or "RAM" . The slide 41 runs inside the carriage 40 along the advancement axis Z and is connected to the carriage 40 by means of a pair of upper carriages 43 and a pair of lower carriages . The pair of upper carriages 43 is arranged on an upper face 44 of the slide 41 , whilst the pair of lower carriages is arranged on a lower face of the slide 41 .

[0033] In addition, the slide 41 extends between a front slide end 41 ' , where the tool-holder table 42 is arranged, and a rear slide end 41" .

[0034] In detail , when the slide 41 translates inside the carriage 40 along the advancement axis Z , the position of the center of gravity G1 of the machining group 4 moves along such an advancement axis Z . In other words , the position of the center of gravity G1 changes as a function of the position of the slide 41 relative to the carriage 40 . Therefore , due to the elasticity of the components of the machine tool 1 , the change in position of the center of gravity G1 changes the attitude of machining group 4 relative to the upright 2 . The change in the attitude of the machining group 4 due to the displacement of the center of gravity G1 is to the detriment of precision mechanics .

[0035] Operationally, in order to compensate for variations in the attitude of the machining group 4 and to comply with the dimensional requirements imposed by precision mechanics , the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 cooperates with the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 in order to keep the machining group 4 orthogonal to the vertical axis Y, independently of the position of the center of gravity G1 .

[0036] According to one embodiment , the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 comprises a front pair of actuating gear motors 510 , 530 and a front pair of ball screws 510 ' , 530 ' .

[0037] A first gear motor 510 of the front pair of actuating gear motors 510 , 530 actuates a first ball screw 510 ' of the front pair of ball screws 510 ' , 530 ' .

[0038] A second gear motor 530 of the front pair of actuating gear motors 510 , 530 actuates a second ball screw 530 ' of the front pair of ball screws 510 ' , 530 ' .

[0039] According to an embodiment , the first gear motor is the master and the second gear motor is the slave. In other words, the front pair of actuating gear motors 510, 530 has a master-slave architecture.

[0040] According to an embodiment, the rear pair of vertical translation means 52, 54 comprises a rear pair of actuating gear motors 520, 540 and a rear pair of ball screws 520', 540' .

[0041] A third gear motor 520 of the rear pair of actuating gear motors 520, 540 actuates a third ball screw 520' of the rear pair of ball screws 520', 540' .

[0042] A fourth gear motor 540 of the rear pair of actuating gear motors 520, 540 actuates a fourth ball screw 540' of the rear pair of ball screws 520' , 540' .

[0043] According to an embodiment, the third gear motor is the master and the second gear motor is the slave. In other words, the rear pair of actuating gear motors 520, 540 has a master-slave architecture.

[0044] In an embodiment, the first gear motor 510 is the master relative to the third gear motor 520, so as to make the rear pair of vertical translation means 52, 54 the slave relative to the first gear motor 510.

[0045] Alternatively, the third gear motor 520 is the master relative to the first gear motor 510, so as to make the front pair of vertical translation means 51, 53 the slave relative to the third gear motor 520. [0046] According to an embodiment , a GANTRY control is provided between each master and the respective slaves .

[0047] Thus , there is a GANTRY control both on the front pair of actuating gear motors 510 , 530 and on the rear pair of actuating gear motors 520 , 540 .

[0048] Furthermore , a GANTRY control is also provided between the front pair of actuating gear motors 510 , 530 and the rear pair of actuating gear motors 520 , 540 . In particular, when the first gear motor 510 is the master relative to the third gear motor 520 or when the third gear motor 520 is the master relative to the first gear motor 510 .

[0049] The GANTRY control is implemented on master-slave architectures wherein, by means of MIMO (Multiple- Input and Multiple-Output ) communication, the slave gear motors follow the positions controlled by the master and send the feedback data thereof to the master, so as to obtain closed-loop control .

[0050] Preferably, the front pair of actuating gear motors 510 , 530 is independent of the rear pair of actuating gear motors 520 , 540 . This particular configuration is known to the skilled person as "decoupling" , i . e . there is no GANTRY control between the front pair of actuating gear motors 510 , 530 and the rear pair of actuating gear motors 520 , 540 . In other words , the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 is completely independent of the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 .

[0051] According to an embodiment , the slide 41 is movable between a forward position ( figure 4b ) and a retracted position ( figure 4 ) . In the forward position, the center of gravity G1 of the machining group 4 is near the front imaginary plane I f and the tool-holder table 42 tends to bend downward . In the retracted position, the center of gravity G1 of the machining group 4 is near the imaginary rear plane Ip and the tool-holder table 42 tends to bend upward .

[0052] Between the forward position and the retracted position there is an intermediate equilibrium position ( figure 4a ) , wherein the center of gravity G1 of the machining group 4 is at an intermediate position between the front imaginary plane I f and the rear imaginary plane Ip so that the front carriage plane Fc is parallel to the front upright plane Fm and the force applied by the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 is essentially coincident with the force applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 .

[0053] In accordance with the attached figures 4-4b, where the carriage 40 engages with the front pair of ball screws 510 ' , 530 ' and where the carriage 40 engages with the rear pair of ball screws 520 ' , 540 ' , directional arrows pointing upwards have been represented graphically indicating the forces wherewith the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 and the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 pull the machining group 4 upward, so as to recover the attitude of the machining group due to the displacement of the center of gravity G1 . The length of the arrows , although not to scale , is indicative of the intensity of the force wherewith the front pair of vertical translation means

51 , 53 and the rear pair of vertical translation means

52 , 54 pull the machining group 4 upwards .

[0054] Figure 4 shows the slide 41 in the retracted position, wherein the rear slide end 41" tends to bend downwards and therefore the force wherewith the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 pulls the machining group 4 upwards is greater than the force applied by the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 .

[0055] Figure 4a shows the slide 41 in an intermediate equilibrium position, wherein the force applied by the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 is substantially coincident with the force applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 .

[0056] Figure 4b shows the slide 41 in the forward position, wherein the front slide end 41 ' tends to bend downward and therefore the force wherewith the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 pulls the machining group 4 upwards is greater than the force applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 .

[0057] Preferably, the displacement of the center of gravity Gl , i . e . the displacement of the center of gravity Gl along the advancement axis Z , is comprised between the imaginary front plane I f and the imaginary rear plane Ip, so that the forces applied by the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 and by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 are always directed upwards . This constraint on the excursion of the center of gravity Gl is due to the fact that i f the center of gravity Gl frontly exceeded the imaginary front plane I f ( or posteriorly exceeded the imaginary rear plane Ip ) , the force applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 ( or by the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 ) would undergo a reversal in direction and would therefore be turned downwards . It has been experimentally observed that a change in direction of the force applied to the carriage 40 by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 ( or by the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 ) results in a situation of instability for the machine tool . [0058] According to an embodiment , in the forward position, the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 apply a force directed upwards which is greater than the one applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 , so as to restore parallelism between the front carriage plane Fc and the front upright plane Fm . In particular, such a front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 counteract the downward bending of the toolholder table 42 by vertically translating the carriage upwards with a front force which is greater than the rear force with which the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 vertically translate the carriage upwards .

[0059] In accordance with an embodiment , in the retracted position, the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 apply a force directed upwards which is smaller than the one applied by the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 , so as to restore parallelism between the front carriage plane Fc and the front upright plane Fm . In particular, such a front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 counteract the upward bending of the tool-holder table 42 by vertically translating the carriage upwards with a front force which is smaller than the rear force with which the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 vertically translate the carriage upwards . [0060] According to an embodiment, the machine tool 1 comprises a first position sensor 61, e.g., a first optical scale, for controlling the positioning of the front pair of vertical translation means 51, 53.

[0061] In one embodiment, the machine tool 1 comprises a second position sensor 62, e.g., a second optical scale, for controlling the positioning of the rear pair of vertical translation means 52, 54.

[0062] In accordance with an embodiment, in the machine tool 1 there is a control unit configured to manage the open-loop operation of the machine, insofar as the every position of the slide 41 has been tested. The control unit controls the movement of the front pair of vertical translation means 51, 53 and the rear pair of vertical translation means 52, 54, so as to keep the front carriage plane Fc always parallel to the front upright plane Fm. In particular, the machine tool 1 has been tested to perform the mapping of each position of the slide 41, wherein at each point of the slide the inclination of the tool-holder table 42 has been measured and the intensity of the front force that the front pair of vertical translation means 51, 53 must apply and the intensity of the rear force that the rear pair of vertical translation means 52, 54 must apply has been defined, so as to always keep the front carriage plane Fc parallel to the front upright plane Fm .

[0063] According to an embodiment , in the machine tool 1 there is a control unit configured to manage the closed- loop operation of the machine . The control unit , in receiving position signals from the first and from the second optical scale , is configured to adj ust the movement of the front pair of vertical translation means

51 , 53 and of the rear pair of vertical translation means

52 , 54 , so as to keep the front carriage plane Fc always parallel to the front upright plane Fm . In other words , the first and second optical scales provide actual dimensions regarding the position of the slide 41 and the control unit compares the actual dimensions with the theoretical dimensions of the slide and imposes a pulling force on the front pair of vertical translation means 51 , 53 and on the rear pair of vertical translation means 52 , 54 , so as to always keep the front carriage plane Fc parallel to the front upright plane Fm .

[0064] Innovatively, the machine tool covered by thi s patent application ful fills the intended purpose thereof . [0065] Advantageously, the machine tool , obj ect of the present application, may also be used for precision mechanics .

[0066] According to an advantageous aspect , the machine tool , obj ect of the present application, allows for immediate compensation of the attitude of the machining group .

[0067] To the embodiments of the machine tool according to the invention, a person skilled in the art , in order to meet contingent needs , may make modi fications , adaptations and replacements of elements with functionally equivalent ones , without leaving the scope of protection of the fol lowing claims . Each of the features described as belonging to a possible embodiment may be obtained independently of the other described embodiments .